Glass vs Metal Pie Pan | Glass vs Metallic Pie Pans

When it comes to baking, you have to make a few important decisions. What kind of pan should I use?

What recipe is best for me? One of the most important decisions you’ll make when it comes to baking is what material your pie pan should be. Glass or metal? Here’s a look at the pros and cons of each option.

Glass pie pans are a popular option because they’re non-stick and oven-safe. They’re also very easy to clean up, which is a plus point. However, they can be more expensive than aluminum and tin-made pie pans.

Metal pie pans are budget-friendly and tend to heat up faster than glass pie pans. However, they can be less non-stick than glass pie pans, and they’re not oven-safe.

So, which is the best option for you? It really depends on your baking requirement and bakeware budget. If you’re looking for a non-stick, oven-safe pie pan, then Glass is the way to go.

If you’re looking for a budget-friendly option, metal pie pans are a good choice, and they heat up quickly.

Glass Pie Pan

Glass pie pans are a popular option because they’re non-stick and oven-safe. However, they can be more expensive than tin-made or aluminum pie pans.

Glass pie pans heat up slowly and evenly, making them an ideal choice for baking thick pies. Because of the natural non-stick surface, your pie will easily come out of the pan. Glass pie pans can be washed in the dishwasher, making cleanup a breeze and getting cleaned very easily.

However, oven-proof glass pie pans are more expensive than other cheap types of pie pans.

Alternatives Of Glass Pie Pans

Ceramic Pie Pans:

It can be tough to decide what cookware to purchase. However, if you’re looking for something that is non-stick and helps your pies turn out perfectly every time, then ceramic pie pans may be the right option for you.

The ceramic pie pans are the perfect alternative to glass pie plates. Both have their own pros and cons, but if you’re looking for an all-around cooking surface that heats evenly, ceramic pie pans are the suitable option. 

Ceramic pie pans are available in various sizes and shapes so that you can find the perfect one for your needs. They’re also non-stick, oven-safe, and freezer-safe so that they can be used for a variety of purposes. 

So, if you’re looking for a versatile and durable pie pan (an alternative to a glass pie pan), consider using a ceramic one.

The Pros And Cons Of Glass Pie Pans

Glass pie pans have many benefits over metal pie pans. 

They are non-stick, so you don’t have to worry about your pie sticking to the pan.

Here, you don’t need to pre-greasing your pie pan like a metallic one.

They are also oven-safe so that you can bake your pie right in the pan.

These pie bakeware are suitable for thick pies; they need more time for complete cooking. If you use metallic pie pans here, the bottom of your pie might get burned.

Glass pie pans are also easy to clean – just wash them with soap and water. Additionally, harsh dishwasher sops and hot water can’t ruin its natural non-stick coating. 

One more thing! I have mentioned to you earlier that you can effortlessly clean your glass pie pan. But always avoid hard scrubbers to wipe off the leftovers. Otherwise, your favorite bakeware will remain with several scratches.

You don’t need to season your glass pie bakeware. So, it is an excellent choice to save money and time by picking these pans.

The glass pie plate can easily get broken because of-

  • If it drops on the hard surface. 
  • You can’t rinse your pie pan just right after you remove the baked pie crust from it.

Metallic Pie Pans

There are a variety of metallic pie pans on the market, including aluminum, tin-made, and steel. All of these pans have their pros and cons, so it’s essential to consider what your needs are before you make a purchase.

Aluminum pie pans are a popular option because they’re lightweight and affordable. However, they can be less durable than other types of metal pie pans, and they’re not non-stick in nature.

Tin-made pie pans are a good choice if you’re looking for a non-stick option. They heat up quickly and evenly, and they’re also oven-safe. However, they can be more expensive than aluminum pie pans.

Steel pie pans are the most durable option available, but they can also be the heaviest. They heat up quickly and evenly, making them a good choice for baking pies. However, they’re not non-stick, and they’re not oven-safe.

The cast-iron pie pans are heavily weighted as compared to other metallic pie pans. They heated up slowly and retained heat for more extended periods.

For your kind information, the cast iron and tin-made pie pans need seasoning; to prevent rust elements.

The Pros And Cons Of Metallic Pie Pans.

Advantages of metal pie pans:

-The metallic pie pans, like disposable aluminum foil made or tin-made, are very affordable. Much cheaper than the glass one.

-This bakeware is heated up quickly and spreads heat evenly, making it a good choice for baking pies. 

The metallic ones are baking a thin pie crust; then, metallic ones are a good option for you. Besides that, if your crust is thick enough, then its bottom might get burned.

-They are highly oven-safe. The stainless steel and cast iron pans oven proof over 450 degrees Fahrenheit. 

-The tin-made and aluminum ones are very affordable. Actually, you can also use disposable aluminum foil pans, which come at even the cheapest rates.

-There is no doubt that metallic pie pans are more durable as compared to glass ones. Atleast, they don’t get broken if they get dropped from your hand.

Disadvantages of metal pie pans:

-All metallic pie pans are not non-stick; that’s why you must grease them before putting a crust on them. In fact, the non-stick metallic pans also need pregreasing to protect their coating. Otherwise, the coating will get ruined, and the pie may stick to the pan.

-The aluminum and tin pie pans are less durable than other pie pans.

– Whether it’s cast iron or ordinary tin-made non-stick bakeware, seasoning is required to protect its performance and durability.

How To Choose A Right Pie Pan For Your Baking Needs?

The fundamental concept behind pie baking, I have already discussed with you.

When it comes to choosing a pie pan, there are a few things you need to consider. The most important factor is what types of pie you want to bake And what flavor you want to add to it.

Glass or ceramic pie bakeware are suitable options for the relatively thicker pie crust. On the other hand, metallic ones are good for a thinner crust.

The thick crust needs slow baking to cook more evenly; glass and ceramic pie bakeware don’t heat up quickly.

The metallic pie pans heated up quickly; that’s why they produced more crunchy and crispy pie crusts.

The correct option is pineapple or baking any other citrus pie crust, stainless steel, glass, and ceramic pie pans.

Apart from these situations, glass pie pans are more expensive than tin-made or aluminum pie pans.

So, which is the best option for you? It really depends on what you are looking for, the pie baking, and the allotted budget for your bakeware.


Is baking with disposable aluminum pie pans safe?

Yes, disposable aluminum baking pans are safe for pie baking. Additionally, it’s cheaper in price.

But, if you are baking any citrus-flavored pies, try to avoid these disposable pans. This metal tends to react with acidic foods.

Does a glass pie pan take longer to bake?

Yes, glass and ceramic pie pans get heated up slowly. That’s why I recommend it for baking thicker pie crusts.

Glass or metal pan what is best for pumpkin pie?

The glass and ceramic pie pans are the first choices. Yes, you can also use cast-iron or aluminum pie pans.

Are glass pie plates better than metal ones?

Well, it depends on what type of pie you are baking. Metallic baking pans are the right choice for the thinner, crunchy non-acidic flavored pie crust. 

Is it ok to bake an apple pie in a metal pan?

Yes, you can bake a crunchy apple pie in a non-stick metallic pie pan.

Conclusion Paragraph: 

Glass pie pans and metallic pie pans both have their advantages and disadvantages. Depending on the pie crust, added flavor, and baking types, you have to choose the right one.

Read More:

Pie pan vs cake pan.

Leave a Comment